Y S Lee

Author of Young Adult, Historical and Mystery Novels

  • Novels
    • A Spy in the House
      • Excerpt: A Spy in the House
      • Deleted scene: A Spy in the House
    • The Body at the Tower
      • Excerpt: The Body at the Tower
      • Deleted scene: The Body at the Tower
    • The Traitor in the Tunnel
      • Excerpt: The Traitor in the Tunnel
      • Deleted scene: The Traitor in the Tunnel
    • Rivals in the City
      • Excerpt: Rivals in the City
      • Deleted scene: Rivals in the City
  • Short Stories
  • Blog
  • About
    • FAQs
  • Visits
You are here: Home / Things I Read / “How the Mid-Victorians Worked, Ate, and Died”

“How the Mid-Victorians Worked, Ate, and Died”

March 27, 2013 By Ying 2 Comments

Hello, friends. Today, I want to point you towards a super-interesting public-health article that analyzes (in broad strokes, obviously) the rural working-class Victorian diet. I don’t know about you but when I think of Victorian cuisine, my first thoughts are of Mrs. Beeton, or else of Victorian celebrity chefs likes Alexis Soyer and Charles Elmé Francatelli. The food is elaborate, involved, constructed: blancmange. Meat boiled forever. Dessert sculpted into the shape of a giraffe.

Or else I think of the hungry poor, who ate whatever they could (ill-)afford: any vegetables they could scrounge, some stale scraps of meat if they were lucky, a lot of cheap bread. As a result, I tend not to think of Victorian food as healthful or appetizing. I had always assumed that the Victorians were much like us: the rich tended to overeat and suffer from diseases of affluence, while the poor remained undernourished.

But this article, by Paul Clayton and Judith Rowbotham, proposes a very different picture: a “superior” diet of fresh meat, fish, vegetables, and seasonal fruits. It argues that by 1850, improvements in farming technology combined with new transportation (bringing fresh food into urban centres) to create an adult life expectancy that “matched or surpassed our own”, and a distinct “health and vitality… [that] that powered the transformation of the urban landscape at home, and drove the great expansion of the British Empire abroad”. Apparently, the average rural Victorian labourer worked hard (and walked as many as 6 miles to and from work), ate a ton (4000 calories a day!), and enjoyed extremely good health as a result.

I haven’t yet read any responses or analyses to this article, but I’m intrigued. There are plenty of gaps – what of the rich, what of the poor, what of the new middle-classes who sat at desks all day? – but I’m willing to buy the case they make for the diets of the labouring classes – at least, in times of plenty. What do you think?

(Thanks to Mark’s Daily Apple, where I first saw the article linked.)

Filed Under: Things I Read Tagged With: diet, food, health, Victorian working-class

Comments

  1. MelodyJ says

    March 30, 2013 at 1:03 am

    I still think it depended on where exactly you fell on the socio-economic ladder. We tend to think in terms of rich, middle class and poor. But each of those groups have sub-sets. A labourer who could read may have been to obtain a slightly higher level job. As a result have access to better food. Think about the servant class. A butler, housekeeper, lady’s maid, and valet had higher status than other servants. I’m thinking that translated into other fields as well.

  2. Ying says

    April 2, 2013 at 9:30 am

    Hi Melody, I completely agree about this concerning a specific sub-population: rural labourers. I haven’t looked into the supporting research, but I’m fascinated by the authors’ claims because they seem to have a large enough population to perform statistical analysis on longevity, causes of death, etc. We’re not talking about outliers, but about a mainstream group, and that’s what I find intriguing.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get my newsletter

powered by TinyLetter

Say hello…

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • E-mail

Search my blog

© Copyright 2019 Y S Lee · All Rights Reserved · Powered by WordPress · Admin